One of the most frequent questions I hear from skilled visa applicants is why a particular occupation code is “applicable and competitive” in one state yet leads practically nowhere in another. The answer lies neither in luck nor in personal interpretation, but in the legal architecture of the state nomination program itself. In this note, Negin Safaee, Registered Migration Agent (MARA 1791573), sets out exactly where the differences between New South Wales, Victoria and South Australia come from — and how you can manage them in favour of your own case.
The short answer
Because state nomination for subclass 190 and 491 is not a federal decision; states and territories assess applicants against criteria that are specific to their own jurisdiction. New South Wales operates on an invitation-only basis and your occupation must fall within a unit group listed on the NSW Skills List; Victoria ranks every Registration of Interest (ROI) using the “Victorian Points Test”; and South Australia runs its own streams and its own occupation list. So one occupation can be highly promising in one state and have no traction at all in another.
What the law says
The legal framework is clear: the Skilled Nominated visa (subclass 190) and the Skilled Work Regional (Provisional) visa (subclass 491) sit under the Migration Act 1958 and the Migration Regulations 1994, and one of their substantive requirements is “nomination by a State or Territory government agency”. Federal law determines that a nomination is required, but the content of that nomination — which occupation, supported by what experience, with what residence requirement and at what priority — is left to the policy of the individual state. As the Department of Home Affairs puts it plainly, states and territories assess applicants against criteria unique to their jurisdiction.
The second layer of difference is the “allocation”. Nomination places are divided among the states each year; for the 2025–26 program the allocations were: New South Wales 2,100 places for subclass 190 and 1,500 places for 491, Victoria 2,700 and 700, and South Australia 1,350 and 900. When capacity, occupation lists and selection criteria all differ at the same time, the natural outcome is that a single occupation meets three different fates across three states.
The third layer is the selection mechanism, and this is where most of the misunderstanding arises:
- New South Wales: New South Wales uses an invitation-based selection process so that its nominees align with the skills needs of the state economy, and you cannot apply directly for nomination by this state. The state also states expressly that its nomination is highly competitive and applicants are advised to explore all other migration pathways rather than simply waiting for an invitation.
- Victoria: Victoria’s skilled visa nomination program uses the “Victorian Points Test” (VPT) to rank all Registrations of Interest (ROI) when selecting candidates for nomination, and each factor contributes to the total ROI score, with ROIs ranked from the highest score to the lowest.
- South Australia: this state administers its own skilled program with separate streams and a dedicated occupation list; the current criteria for each stream must be verified directly from the official South Australian Government skilled migration program page.
An important legal point: because nomination is a decision of the state government agency and not of the Department of Home Affairs, each state has its own internal procedure for reviewing and dealing with nomination decisions. The correct approach, therefore, is to follow the published procedure of that particular state program, rather than assuming a single uniform review pathway applies across all states.
Each state’s key criteria at a glance
The three states in question apply three different selection logics:
| Issue | New South Wales | Victoria | South Australia |
|---|---|---|---|
| How you enter | You cannot apply directly for nomination; you must be invited | Submit an ROI, ranked via the VPT | Submit an EOI/ROI under the stream published by the state (per that program’s official page) |
| Occupation requirement | Your occupation must fall within one of the ANZSCO unit groups listed on the NSW Skills List and must also be eligible for that particular visa | Victoria’s eligible occupation list, combined with the “occupation skill level” points in the VPT | South Australia’s skilled occupation list, broken down by stream |
| Residence/employment requirement | One of three: employment in New South Wales in the nominated occupation; or continuous residence in New South Wales for at least six months; or continuous residence outside Australia for at least six months | Employment is not an entry requirement; income from skilled employment in Victoria is a points factor “if applicable” | Varies by stream (graduate, working in the state, offshore, and so on) |
| 2025–26 allocation | 2,100 (190) and 1,500 (491) | 2,700 (190) and 700 (491) | 1,350 (190) and 900 (491) |
The Victorian Points Test (VPT): seven ranking factors
Victoria has published its mechanism transparently. The factors are: age, English language level, years of experience in the nominated occupation, qualification, occupation skill level, partner skills (if applicable) and annual income from skilled employment in Victoria (if applicable). A few examples from the official tables:
- English language: Competent zero points, Proficient one hundred points and Superior two hundred points — meaning English is one of the heaviest levers in the ranking.
- Work experience in the nominated occupation: from zero points for no experience up to 100 points for more than eight years.
- Annual income from current skilled employment in Victoria: starts at 8 points for the $80,000 to $84,999 band and rises to 150 points for $170,000 and above.
The legal analysis of this table matters: income in Victoria is not a “mandatory threshold”, but one of seven factors ranking your ROI, and it is only counted “if applicable”. Victoria also accepts applicants living outside Australia into the program; so the legally accurate description is that the income points are a competitive advantage for those who already hold skilled employment in Victoria, not a barrier to entry for everyone else.
What this means for you
As Negin Safaee, Registered Migration Agent (MARA 1791573), explains, the practical outcome of these three layers (occupation list, allocation, selection mechanism) comes down to one simple sentence: “your occupation’s chances” are not a single national figure; they must be calculated separately for each state. If your profile does not include a high Victorian income, that does not mean you are out of the running; it means you need to build your competitive weight through the other avenues within the same test — such as lifting your English from Proficient to Superior, or consolidating years of experience in your nominated occupation — because Victoria’s official tables allow up to 200 points for English and 100 points for more than eight years of experience.
For New South Wales, the focus must be on two things: confirming that your occupation genuinely falls within a listed unit group and is also eligible for that particular visa, and then documenting one of the three residence/employment scenarios. And because the state itself warns that this nomination is highly competitive and you should not simply wait for an invitation, the professional strategy is to have your case ready to act on more than one pathway at the same time. As for South Australia, every decision must be based on the current criteria for the relevant stream on that state government’s official page — not on hearsay.
The good news is that this very complexity is an opportunity: when three programs apply three different logics, a strong professional profile will almost always be competitive in one of them. It simply needs to be chosen correctly and documented correctly.
Sources
- Victorian Points Test — Live in Melbourne, Victorian Government (version published for the current program, October 2026): liveinmelbourne.vic.gov.au/migrate/skilled-migration-visas/vpt
- Skilled Nominated visa (subclass 190) — NSW Government: nsw.gov.au/visas-and-migration/skilled-visas/skilled-nominated-visa-subclass-190
- State and territory nomination allocations — Australian Department of Home Affairs (2025–26 allocations, updated September 2026): immi.homeaffairs.gov.au/what-we-do/state-and-territory-nomination-allocations
- Migration Regulations 1994 (the legal framework for the state nomination requirement for subclass 190 and 491) — Federal Register of Legislation: legislation.gov.au
Your case, the right state
If you want to know which state your occupation code is genuinely competitive in today, a careful profile assessment can remove months of fruitless waiting from your pathway. In that assessment, your federal points score, your standing in the Victorian Points Test, the New South Wales residence/employment requirement and the appropriate South Australian stream are all placed side by side, so that your decision rests on official criteria rather than guesswork. For advice tailored specifically to your own case, contact Negin Safaee, Registered Migration Agent (MARA 1791573).
Frequently asked questions
Why do the chances for one occupation code differ between Australian states?
Because state nomination is not a decision of the Department of Home Affairs. The Department states expressly that states and territories assess applicants against criteria unique to their jurisdiction; each state has its own occupation list, annual allocation and selection mechanism.
Do I need a job in Victoria to be nominated by Victoria?
No. Annual income from skilled employment in Victoria is one of the seven ranking factors in the Victorian Points Test (VPT), and according to the official page it is only counted “if applicable” — that is, a competitive advantage for those already working in Victoria, not an entry requirement.
At what figure do the income points in the Victorian Points Test begin?
According to Victoria’s official table, income points start at 8 points for the $80,000 to $84,999 band and reach 150 points for income of $170,000 and above.
Can I apply directly for New South Wales nomination?
No. New South Wales uses an invitation-based selection process and direct application is not possible. Your occupation must fall within an ANZSCO unit group listed on the NSW Skills List and must also be eligible for that particular visa.
What is the New South Wales residence requirement for subclass 190?
One of three scenarios: employment in New South Wales in the nominated occupation; or continuous residence in New South Wales for at least six months; or continuous residence outside Australia for at least six months.
How much do state nomination allocations affect my chances?
They have a direct effect. For the 2025–26 program, New South Wales had 2,100 places for 190 and 1,500 for 491, Victoria 2,700 and 700, and South Australia 1,350 and 900; less capacity means tougher selection within the same occupation list.
This answer reflects the law and policy as verified on October 31, 2026. Immigration rules change frequently — confirm the current position before acting.
Mrs. Negin Safaee Registered Migration Agent 1791573
This article is general information only, current at the date shown, and is not legal advice. Do not rely on it for your own situation — immigration law and policy change frequently. Seek advice from a registered migration agent or immigration lawyer about your circumstances.
